Salvaging Democracy


Ferdinand Marcos: Iron Butterfly

Salvaging Democracy


THE MAIN CONCERN of a nasty govt, as we all know, is to give protection to itself from its personal topics. Below martial regulation, the Philippines entered a grim duration of human rights abuses. A brand new time period, “salvaging,” got here into use to hide the torture, disappearance, and loss of life of unusual electorate. The military and Constabulary got down to self-discipline the inhabitants by means of developing an environment of terror. Right here and there a couple of just right officials attempted to win the enhance of the native inhabitants, and punished troops who abused civilians. However they have been uncommon exceptions.

Lots of the horror tales have been independently corroborated by means of diplomats, reporters, clergymen, students, and world organizations akin to Amnesty World. They’re a litany of sadism, of useless rats being crammed in mouths, of electrical farm animals prods jammed into vaginas, of mashed testicles, and prisoners being compelled to consume their very own ears. Those atrocities have been frequently carried out by means of, or supervised by means of, males educated and hired in more than a few techniques by means of the U.S. army and intelligence services and products. Those have been the folk produced by means of the Colonel Lansdale and Frank Walton systems, and educated at more than a few police and safety academies in The united states and Taiwan. They have been the brand new mixed military-police status quo supplied to Ferdinand Marcos as a part of his take care of Lyndon Johnson. With their lend a hand, Ferdinand was once ready first to drive his personal re-election, then to claim martial regulation and make it stick. Now they have been the software during which he would suppress all dissent and retain continual for himself and his circle of relatives so long as he wanted. The U.S. Embassy was once no longer ignorant of those practices. Legit protests weren’t made underneath Presidents Nixon, Ford, and Reagan — best right through the presidency of Jimmy Carter — however the Carter management didn’t apply thru by means of halting over $500 million in army assist from going to the Philippines.

Below the Marcoses, the military, Constabulary, Civilian House Protection Corps, and intelligence companies hired such strategies as “submarine,” the place your head was once submerged in a bathroom or bucket of water; “zap-zap,” the place electrical shocks have been carried out for your genitals or nipples; “water-cure,” the place gallons of water have been poured up your nostril until you virtually drowned; “saggy,” the place a plastic bag was once positioned over your head until you just about suffocated; “buttstroking,” the place you have been overwhelmed at the again with a rifle; “phone,” the place your eardrums have been popped from at the back of with the residences of the hand; “Saigon roulette,” the place the torturer loaded all yet one spherical in a revolver and fired at your legs. And, in fact, “San Juanico Bridge,” the place you have been compelled to lie together with your ft on one mattress and your head on a 2d, and have been overwhelmed and kicked each time you let your frame sag — named after the brand new bridge connecting Samar to Leyte, constructed as a marriage anniversary provide to Imelda from Ferdinand. The Marcoses referred to as it the “bridge of affection.”

Those human rights abuses got here from each ends of the army ladder: provincial bullies, and high-ranking sadists at headquarters in Manila. Of the bullies, the archetype was once Constabulary Sergeant George Presquito on Negros Island, a sweaty guy with a large abdomen, scraggly beard, and a drunken means, even if he was once sober, which was once uncommon.

Presquito was once well-known for capturing individuals who had already surrendered, even if their offenses have been minor. He was once stated to have murdered forty-two other people for my part. The federal government and army by no means interfered. He cherished to undress and sexually abuse ladies in entrance in their husbands or their households, which he discovered produced fast effects. He led his males on sprees the place they beat and robbed villagers. He faithful himself to tormenting political activists and union organizers.

It was once Presquito and his males who one morning in July 1977 picked up Vilma Riopay, a twenty-one-year-old catechist on the Magballo church, and brutally tormented her till she was once was a psychological and bodily invalid. The case was once so stunning that it seemed in newspapers and publications all over the world. She have been taken to a secure space the place she underwent an interrogation that incorporated the “zap-zap,” the “water-cure,” denial of sleep, and beating on her genitals. After the federal government won 1000’s of petitions from villagers in Negros, Presquito was once in any case referred to as into Constabulary headquarters at Camp Crame in Manila. In spite of the entire proof and witnesses, an army court docket exonerated him. Presquito, the court docket made up our minds, was once simply doing his accountability.

Within one of the crucial constructions of Camp Crame was once the headquarters of the feared fifth CSU (Constabulary Safety Unit). The fifth CSU created many martyrs, yet few as celebrated as Edgar Jopson, the coed chief who had requested President Marcos to signal a pledge that he would no longer violate the charter and search a 3rd time period. His disagreement with Ferdinand had climaxed within the scholar siege of Malacanang Palace, and then Jopson was once compelled to escape for his lifestyles. He went underground as considered one of a rising collection of complaint guerrillas. He had by no means been a Communist or a thorough yet have been the “guy of the yr” of the middle-class Jaycees. Ultimately, he joined the Communist-led NPA, turning into considered one of its commanders. Jopson was once captured on June 14, 1979, and underwent torture on the fifth CSU for plenty of months.

The use of cash given him on visiting day by means of his father, Jopson “befriended” a guard and escaped. He was once recaptured in Mindanao in the summertime of 1982, shot 3 times, after which later six occasions extra to complete him off. His bloated and bullet-ridden frame was once became over to his father by means of the Constabulary. The slaying brought about an outcry in Manila, specifically at his alma mater, the elite Jesuit-run Ateneo, the place a memorial carrier was once scheduled. It was once referred to as off in the beginning when threats have been won from the military, yet was once held anyway after a typhoon of protest from its prosperous alumni, which incorporated Ninoy Aquino.

The person accused by means of human rights teams of being “the highest torturer” on the fifth CSU, a type of stated to have tormented Edgar Jopson, was once Captain Rodolfo Aguinaldo. In line with his accusers, Aguinaldo was once a legend in his personal time, feared during the archipelago: a person whose abilities left detainees completely disabled or mentally crippled. Aguinaldo was once a Marcos favourite, a fellow Ilocano from Laoag. He graduated 2d in his category on the Philippine Army Academy within the overdue Nineteen Sixties and right away joined the fifth CSU. He won particular coaching from American military and CIA instructors within the positive artwork of extracting knowledge. After proving himself to be strangely proficient, he was once despatched to the CIA/KMT Political Battle Cadres Academy in Taiwan, the place he won further coaching from the past-masters of the Chiang dictatorship. Aguinaldo was once a trim and muscular athlete, who liked jogging fits with a Belgian 9mm Browning tucked within the waistband. He cherished to swim and skydive, one of the crucial favourite sports activities of his final boss, Constabulary leader Basic Fidel Ramos. In line with a learn about of human rights abuses within the Philippines printed by means of the Catholic Church, the game Aguinaldo loved maximum was once having intercourse with the other halves, sisters, or daughters of his prisoners. None of those fees had any impact on his profession.

The pinnacle of fifth CSU was once any other Ilocano, Colonel Ishmael Rodrigo, whose folks got here from the Marcos fatherland, Batac. He served with Fidel Ramos within the Filipino contingent right through the Korean Struggle, turned into considered one of Lansdale’s peak Huk killers, and labored for the CIA in Manila and Saigon. In time he transferred without delay to the U.S. Military Inexperienced Berets as an intelligence officer with the rank of colonel. In Vietnam, Rodrigo turned into buddies with William Colby, and was once despatched to CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia, to review tradecraft. After the declaration of martial regulation, the CIA despatched Rodrigo again to Manila, the place Basic Ramos gave him the task of operating fifth CSU. Thus the person heading probably the most infamous torture unit within the Marcos dictatorship was once a long-time CIA agent and Inexperienced Beret. It was once Colonel Rodrigo who carried out brainwashing tactics to younger Edgar Jopson, then became him over to Captain Aguinaldo’s males for bodily abuse.

Aguinaldo was once assisted in his efforts by means of Main Cesar Garcia and Colonel Miguel Aure, each rabid anti-Communists. Colonel Aure had directed the 1977 torture, rape, and homicide of Purificacion Pedro, a twenty-eight-year-old graduate of the College of the Philippines arrested on suspicion of being a member of the NPA. She was once shot within the shoulder right through the arrest and overwhelmed with rifle butts. Then she was once taken to a Bataan sanatorium, the place she was once gang-raped and hung by means of her neck along with her brassiere. Because the soldiers left her room, the colonel reportedly growled at her kinfolk ready outdoor: “Take into account the call Aure.”

There have been many warring parties of the Marcos regime who drew consideration to what was once taking place within the Philippines, yet as long as Nixon and Kissinger remained in keep watch over, Washington was once firmly at the facet of the dictatorship. Not anything was once performed to lend a hand political prisoners, and an excellent deal was once performed to intimidate anti-Marcos exiles residing in The united states.

Senator Aquino have been arrested within the early hours of September 23, 1972, in his suite within the Manila Hilton. Two days later he petitioned the Ideally suited Court docket from his mobile for a writ of habeas corpus, difficult the validity of martial regulation, his arrest, and detention. The petition was once denied.

A yr later he was once charged with homicide, subversion, and unlawful ownership of firearms. The homicide rate associated with the loss of life of a barrio captain in Tarlac in 1967. The subversion and unlawful ownership of firearms fees concerned accusations that Ninoy provided palms to Communist terrorists to overthrow the Marcos regime. Ahead of an army court docket, Aquino spoke back that Marcos had merely framed him, and he accused Juan Ponce Enrile without delay of trumping up the fees. He refused to shield himself, announcing he would slightly “settle for a tyrant’s revenge.” The federal government-controlled press didn’t elevate any portion of Aquino’s remark, yet a videotape was once made and saved by means of Imelda, and she or he was once stated to check it every now and then when she felt the want to refresh her sentiments.

Early in 1975, Aquino went on a starvation strike. On the finish of the thirty-first day, he was once rushed to a sanatorium, all the way down to 124 kilos from his authentic 191. His legs now not supported him and he had problem focusing his eyes. His extended speedy produced a profound spiritual enjoy, from which he emerged and slowly regained a few of his well being.

In overdue June 1977, he was once granted a two-and-a-half-hour interview with Ferdinand. As outdated fraternity brothers, they nonetheless addressed each and every different as “brod,” despite the fact that by means of this level the impact will have to were surreal. Ferdinand stated: “Do you keep in mind that I despatched a message to you two days earlier than the declaration of martial regulation that I can claim martial regulation? Smartly, I in point of fact sought after you to run away.” Aquino spoke back, “I instructed the messenger that I’m a senator of the republic and I can stick by means of my place — and I used to be arrested.” Aquino requested that his case be transferred to a civilian court docket, yet Ferdinand became him down.

On November 25, an army tribunal discovered Aquino in charge and pronounced his sentence — “loss of life by means of firing squad.” On account of the hot election of President Carter, the sentence was once no longer performed. Carter made repeated representations to Manila thru emissaries.

In June 1978, an settlement was once reached with Cory Aquino that her husband would observe for amnesty and write a letter expressing his want to reside outdoor the rustic, promising that whilst in a foreign country he would no longer “take any motion that will have an effect on the picture and safety of the rustic.” This was once performed, yet motion was once not on time on more than a few excuses, reportedly as a result of drive from the vengeful First Woman.

Whilst Aquino was once being neutralized on this means, others have been starting to strike again. Right through the summer season and fall of 1979, quite a lot of govt and industrial constructions in Manila have been put to the torch, together with a floating on line casino moored on the bayfront which was once owned and operated underneath martial regulation coverage by means of Imelda’s brothers Kokoy and Alfredo. The fires have been the paintings of a gaggle calling itself the Mild-a-Hearth Motion.

Fabian Ver’s safety forces gave the impression helpless to forestall the arson. However that December they arrested an American citizen, Ben Lim, at Manila World Airport and charged him with making an attempt to smuggle explosives into the rustic. Lim had a vulnerable middle and when his capsules have been withheld right through his confinement, he died. His interrogation resulted in the arrest of fifteen different “terrorists,” reportedly all individuals of the Mild-a-Hearth Motion, headed by means of a Harvard-educated trade govt, Eduardo Olaguer. A raid on Olaguer’s house produced explosives and instruction manuals with CIA markings. It was once alleged that the explosives have been despatched from San Francisco by means of attorney Steve Psinakis, son-in-law of Eugenio Lopez. Psinakis have been a thorn within the facet of Ferdinand and Imelda for the reason that Lopez showdown. He printed common assaults at the regime in books, pamphlets, and newspapers, and saved up a gentle barrage of the U.S. Congress protesting the unlawful seizure of Lopez circle of relatives property within the Philippines. In 1977, Psinakis helped prepare and perform a bold prison spoil at Castle Bonifacio to spring his brother-in-law, Eugenio Lopez, Jr., and fellow prisoner Sergio Osmeña III. Since then, Psinakis have been lively within the Motion for a Loose Philippines headed by means of Raul Manglapus. He was once now accused of being at the back of the Mild-a-Hearth Motion.

Through the tip of December 1979, greater than 2 hundred women and men have been arrested as “attainable assets of knowledge.” All the ones arrested have been instructed they might pass unfastened in the event that they signed statements that Psinakis was once in charge. Those that didn’t settle for the be offering have been tortured till they signed anyway. However quickly in a while, Ferdinand introduced that the Mild-a-Hearth Motion have been extinguished and Aquino was once unfastened to head.

The senator’s lengthy imprisonment had taken a toll on his middle. Docs stated he wanted bypass surgical procedure. This may have been performed at Imelda’s sumptuous Center Middle, yet no person in Manila had the unhealthy style to signify it. He and his circle of relatives have been unexpectedly, with only some hours’ realize, put aboard a aircraft to america.

Imelda, the objective of Aquino’s frequently satirical complaint, for my part introduced him the phrase that he was once unfastened to depart. Then, in his presence, she gaily telephoned key males on the international ministry, U.S. Ambassador Richard Murphy, and Philippine Air Strains to prepare his hasty departure.

After present process a triple bypass operation, Aquino settled along with his circle of relatives in Boston on a grant from Harvard College. He then officially broke the vow extracted from him in Manila that he would chorus from making political statements. Attacking the settlement as “a pact with the satan,” he warned President Marcos of a “amassing typhoon.” Idealistic teams of Filipinos have been making ready to strike on the dictatorship with “bombings, assassinations and kidnappings of public officers and army officials … to carry the Marcos regime to its knees.”

Not up to 3 weeks later, the assaults started. Bombs exploded concurrently in 9 constructions after the occupants have been warned to evacuate. No person was once harm yet world press protection was once heavy. In October 1980, the crowd struck once more as delegates accrued in Manila for a practice of the American Society of Go back and forth Brokers. The environment was once Imelda’s $150 million Conference Middle. A bomb exploded best fifty ft from Ferdinand Marcos. He was once no longer injured yet twenty others have been, and the conference was once canceled in panic. Manila’s luxurious resorts emptied and stayed empty. American tourism have been bringing the regime $400 million a yr. Malacanang Palace issued thirty arrest warrants, together with one for Aquino. There was once no extradition settlement between america and the Philippines, so Aquino was once secure in the meanwhile.

Requested what the U.S. govt would do in regards to the warrants, an reputable of the Carter management stated, “Not anything — [Washington] would no longer bend the regulation to fit Manila.” That stand was once reversed a couple of months later when Ronald Reagan turned into president.

The turnabout underneath Reagan started with the arrest in Manila of a U.S. citizen accused of being concerned within the Mild-a-Hearth Motion. Victor Burns Pretty was once a fifty-eight-year-old Filipino-American businessman from Los Angeles. He arrived in Manila with a bomb in his baggage, checked right into a lodge, and when he unpacked the bomb exploded, blowing off his proper forearm and blinding one eye. Pretty was once taken to an army sanatorium and interrogated. Ver’s brokers instructed him he was once at the 7th ground and someone falling from that peak would no longer live to tell the tale. Pretty signed a confession. President Marcos confirmed up for the instance and was once photographed waving the confession over Pretty.

Within the confession, Pretty stated his go back and forth have been deliberate and bankrolled by means of Aquino and Psinakis. He claimed Psinakis had despatched him to a secret camp in Arizona the place he was once urged in the usage of bombs by means of the American-based Motion for a Loose Philippines.

The FBI turned into concerned as a result of Pretty was once an American citizen. The FBI had no longer proven equivalent passion previous with Ben Lim. The explanation was once easy — a coverage choice had since been made by means of the Reagan management to lend a hand the Marcoses by means of interfering with the exile motion. FBI brokers have been despatched to Manila to query Pretty about Aquino and Psinakis. Secretary of State Alexander Haig met privately with President Marcos and promised him that the Reagan management would lend a hand “battle terrorism” by means of vigorously prosecuting U.S.-based Filipino activists.

Quickly after Reagan turned into president, Ferdinand Marcos started lobbying arduous for an extradition treaty in order that he may just get his arms on a few of his enemies in exile. He may just then body felony fees towards someone he wanted. This kind of treaty was once proposed within the U.S. Congress yet was once defeated in spite of the most productive efforts of the Reagan management to push it thru. The principle reason why for its defeat was once the fear of Congress to tell apart between political warring parties of a international govt and not unusual criminals — a difference that many foresaw could be blurred intentionally by means of the Marcos regime. Not able to use extradition, the Reagan management became subsequent to the Neutrality Act, which prohibits American citizens from attractive in conspiracy to overthrow pleasant governments. Through Reagan’s estimation, the Marcos regime was once pleasant, it doesn’t matter what its document of human rights abuses.

After being terrorized by means of Ver’s thugs, Victor Pretty was once understandably fearful to return to The united states underneath any circumstance, at the same time as a federal witness. He was once returned to america in September 1981. In line with FBI affidavits, Pretty repeated his fees earlier than a grand jury that Psinakis arranged the Manila bombings. Even supposing grand jury complaints are meant to be secret, Pretty’s testimony was once became over by means of the FBI to Malacanang. FBI brokers puzzled Aquino and Manglapus intently. Aquino have been underneath extensive FBI surveillance since he arrived in america and his space in Boston was once raided.

FBI brokers additionally raided the Psinakis house in San Francisco on December 17, 1981. Twenty brokers seemed in the dead of night accompanied by means of San Francisco police and sheriff’s deputies. Psinakis and his circle of relatives have been locked within the kitchen whilst brokers thumbed thru his information, slit open vacuum cleaner luggage, unwrapped Christmas gifts, and searched each and every room with canine educated to smell out explosives. The FBI claimed {that a} “confidential supply” (it appears that evidently posing as a baglady) had poked thru Psinakis trash barrels that morning and located 600 ft of detonating twine, an empty battery package deal, a field for a Westclox pocket-watch, and 2 orange rubber gloves. However no proof of bomb-making was once discovered that night time nor when a 2d seek was once made in January.

Right through those raids the FBI got rid of quite a lot of paperwork from Psinakis’s information, together with a coded checklist of underground anti-Marcos operatives within the Philippines. Those have been became over by means of the FBI to Basic Ver, who had the ones named arrested, interrogated, and tortured. A type of arrested was once Doris Nueval, who was once interrogated within the Philippines no longer best by means of Ver’s brokers yet by means of the FBI and the CIA as properly. Two of the ones arrested and interrogated vanished with out a hint.

Ferdinand had turn out to be paranoid about his critics in The united states. He and Imelda it appears that evidently mentioned the topic time and again with their buddies the Reagans in long-distance telephone calls with the White Area — private touch that they saved up during the Reagan presidency. Division of State stories on Filipino dissidents have been automatically despatched to the embassy in Manila, to be shared with Marcos and Ver.[2]

Whilst Washington hounded Ferdinand’s enemies, not anything was once performed to forestall Ver’s secret brokers from hanging at enemies within america. The FBI, Justice Division, and State Division stated that the presence in The united states of intelligence brokers of such “pleasant” nations because the Philippines, Chile, and Iran didn’t provide a threat. In line with a secret U.S. Senate document, the Justice Division didn’t believe nationwide safety to be threatened if brokers of pleasant nations — Ver’s NISA or the Shah’s SAVAK — got here to The united states to threaten and harass dissidents in an effort to curtail their political actions. Officers did admit that the actions of Ver’s brokers incorporated the “chance of violence.” However any “court cases” would must be treated on a case-by-case foundation.

In line with one FBI agent, it was once a very easy utility of “white hat-black hat” standards. Because the Philippines was once no longer Communist — a black hat — it was once just right and wore a “white hat.” No fear was once expressed over unusual proof of Marcos involvement in corruption, embezzlement, extortion, robbery, torture, homicide, and arranged crime.

The CIA automatically knowledgeable each the FBI and the State Division when it realized that NISA brokers had entered america. The CIA reported that Ver despatched nineteen NISA brokers to america in Might 1973 as “bodyguards” for Imee Marcos, when she attended Princeton. In simply one of the instances, in February 1974, the FBI realized that six NISA brokers have been despatched to Los Angeles to observe Sergio Osmeña, Jr., who had run towards Ferdinand within the 1969 presidential race. It was once additionally recognized {that a} army attaché on the Philippine Embassy in Washington was once concerned complete time in surveillance of exile leaders, and {that a} NISA agent was once founded in Chicago the place considered one of his tasks was once to care for liaison with Tony Accardo, chairman of the board of the mob. In line with exiled chief Raul Manglapus, Basic Ver as soon as traveled to Chicago to prepare his homicide. Manglapus stated Ver approached a Filipino exile and instructed him that President Marcos would drop all fees towards him if he agreed to assassinate Manglapus. As an alternative, the Filipino were given phrase to Manglapus that Ver had made this be offering and that he had became it down.

In June 1981 in Seattle two Filipino-American exertions leaders, Gene Viernes and Silme Domingo, who have been seeking to prepare opposition to Marcos within the exertions motion, have been shot to loss of life. Their households charged that the murders have been performed by means of NISA brokers on orders from President Marcos and Fabian Ver. 3 individuals of a U.S.-based pro-Marcos gang have been convicted and sentenced to lifestyles; a fourth member of the group was once murdered simply earlier than he was once to provide testimony towards Anthony Baruso, proprietor of the homicide weapon, implicating him within the conspiracy. Baruso was once an Ilocano and an intimate of Ferdinand and Imelda, who was once on a first-name foundation with Ver’s guards at Malacanang Palace. The households of Viernes and Domingo charged that U.S. intelligence companies have been mindful that the homicide was once being deliberate, and that Baruso was once by no means indicted as a result of he was once being safe by means of the CIA and FBI on the request of Basic Ver.

Ferdinand was once to begin with named as a defendant along side his govt within the 1982 lawsuit, yet this was once dropped on the request of the U.S. State Division. Below the “Head-of-State Doctrine,” the chief of a international country can’t be prosecuted for acts undertaken whilst he was once head of state. The attorney for Domingo and Viernes argued that Marcos, despite the fact that immune underneath the doctrine, must nonetheless be required to testify. The true objective of the “Head-of-State Doctrine” is to forestall embarrassment to the U.S. govt.


To what extent have been American officers acutely aware of what Ferdinand and Imelda have been doing? The CIA was once demonstrably mindful that the Marcoses have been looting the Philippines and embezzling loads of thousands and thousands. The CIA was once in detail conversant in the character and extent of torture and political homicide underneath means within the Philippines as a result of lots of the ones concerned have been males educated by means of the CIA, and in some instances have been nonetheless at the payroll offering the Company with within intelligence.

Via get entry to I used to be given to 12 thousand pages of top-secret CIA paperwork protecting a whole yr of intelligence summaries to the White Area, it’s imaginable to mention that little or no of the darkish facet of the Marcos regime was once conveyed without delay to the president of america right through that duration. This was once most definitely because of the manipulations of the director of central intelligence, the secretary of state, and individuals of the Nationwide Safety Council, all of whom would have had reason why to change what the president was once instructed. However it’s mistaken to suppose the president would act another way. President Johnson knew that the Marcos conflict document was once a complete sham, yet counseled it publicly to realize enhance for his Vietnam coverage. President Nixon and Secretary of State Kissinger have been pleased with President Marcos, as they have been with President Pinochet, and so they gave him the nod to usurp continual. The human rights tasks of President Carter have been reversed the instant Reagan received place of job. Those males and their insurance policies weren’t impressed by means of higher intelligence reporting.

When Imelda was once faced by means of a gaggle of U.S. congressmen in 1978 with questions on her hidden wealth and documented instances of beatings, water torture, and electrical surprise remedies being administered to enemies of the regime, she shrugged all of it off. “The tales have … been made up,” she stated.

Ferdinand Marcos 2
Ferdinand Marcos
Ferdinand Marcos 2
Ferdinand Marcos
Ferdinand Marcos 3
Ferdinand Marcos
Ferdinand Marcos 4
Ferdinand Marcos
Ferdinand Marcos 5
Ferdinand Marcos






Manila Philippines Map 1
Manila Philippines Map
Manila Philippines seal
Manila Philippines seal
Manila Philippines Coat of Arms
Manila Philippines Coat of Fingers
Manila Philippines Flag
Manila Philippines Flag

The put up Ferdinand Marcos: Salvaging Democracy seemed first on Journalism and the Information.

Cross to Supply
Creator: Andrew Russell

Debate Bot

By Debate Bot

I'm a machine, but that doesn't mean I haven't read the resolution. I see more than a few interesting words and I'm scouring the internet for something you can use in your debates. Nothing is fabricated and the links (generally) take you to the originally published information.